COURSE PRICE: $6.00
CONTACT HOURS: 1.5
This course will expire or be updated on or before February 1, 2015.
ABOUT THIS COURSE
You must score 70% or better on the test and complete the course evaluation to earn a certificate of completion for this CE activity.
ACCREDITATION / APPROVAL
Wild Iris Medical Education is an approved provider for paramedic and EMT continuing education in California by the Coastal Valleys EMS Agency: CE Provider #49-0057.
This course is appropriate for EMTs, paramedics, and first responders.
Wild Iris Medical Education, Inc. provides educational activities that are free from bias. The information provided in this course is to be used for educational purposes only. It is not intended as a substitute for professional health care. See our disclosures for more information.
Copyright © 2012 Wild Iris Medical Education, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
COURSE OBJECTIVE: The purpose of this course is to inform healthcare professionals of the causes, symptoms, stages, management, and prevention of job burnout.
Upon completion of this course, you will be able to:
Carol Diligent, RN, is a team leader in a locked unit at the state psychiatric hospital. Because of recent staff shortages, she has been required to work double shifts with dangerously low staff/patient ratios. She used to feel good about her job and confident that, even though her patients were severely impaired, she was making a difference in their lives. Lately, however, she has been emotionally and physically exhausted and can’t seem to relax. She has been having “nervous headaches,” stomach pains, and mood swings, exploding in rage one moment and bursting into tears the next.
To survive, Carol has become distant and detached from her team members and patients. Hers is a multicultural workplace, and Carol is frustrated that many of her foreign-born coworkers do not share her values or understand her approach to problems. Some even openly deride Carol and, she suspects, talk to one another about her in their native language. Others have complained to the supervisor about her attitude. Carol knows she is not managing the situation well, but the stress of the job and lack of support from her supervisor are wearing her down. She feels angry, trapped, insecure, inadequate, and a bit fearful she will lose her job.
Carol is suffering from what Maslach and others call burnout, a maladaptive response to stress. The disorder is characterized by emotional exhaustion, detachment, and a reduced sense of personal accomplishment (2009). Caregivers like Carol are especially vulnerable to job burnout. They work in demanding situations, hold high expectations for themselves, and believe they should be able to handle anything no matter what the challenge. Fortunately, the condition is treatable and preventable. Caregivers like Carol can learn to cope with stress and burnout by gaining an understanding of stress and stressors, recognizing the signs and symptoms of job burnout, acquiring skills to manage its destructive effects, and preventing its occurrence in the future.
The idea of stress began with the pioneering work of Walter Cannon (1871–1945). He investigated the sympathetic nervous system as it reacts to heat and noticed that the body responds in a predictable sequence. Han Selye carried on the work of Cannon, defining stress as the “rate of wear and tear on the body” and stressors as the “causative agents of stress” (1956). Selye found that stressors may be physical, such as infection, injury, and pain, or may be psychological, such as fear, anger, and sadness. He identified what he called a general adaptation syndrome (GAS), whereby the body seeks to maintain homeostasis, or balance, first by producing an alarm reaction, then by resisting the effects of stress, and finally by giving in to overwhelming stress.
GENERAL ADAPTATION SYNDROME (GAS)
Exhaustion sets in as the individual fails to adapt to stressors and becomes exhausted.
Source: Adapted from Selye, 1956.
Lazarus (1966) enlarged our understanding of stress and the ways people deal with it when he observed that, when individuals view a new or evolving situation, they first decide whether it is a threat. He called this primary appraisal. Then, as people further monitor a threat, they evaluate their ability to cope with it by what Lazarus called secondary appraisal. In this second step of appraisal, individuals judge themselves unable to handle the situation and withdraw. Others, especially caregivers, are apt to believe they “should” be able to handle anything and attempt to do so, no matter how great the cost. These individuals are at high risk of reaching the end stage of stress: exhaustion.
Instead of persisting until they reach the state of exhaustion, caregivers can learn more effective coping strategies, become self-aware, acknowledge their own limitations, and acquire emotion-focused and problem-solving skills. Managers can provide physical and emotional support for staff members because they value them and understand the stressful nature of their work. Caregivers can do much to prevent burnout in patients by supporting and nurturing them through what may be a long and stressful illness.
Carol, our caregiver, felt overworked and underappreciated. At some point she realized (primary appraisal) she was overpowered by an entrenched bureaucracy and out-numbered by an unsympathetic staff. She realized she was not performing at the level she expected of herself, and she felt guilty, insecure, inadequate, and fearful she might lose her job.
To cope, Carol began using a strategy she had seen others employ: detachment and dissociation. After a while she realized (secondary appraisal) her method of coping was not solving the problem; the situation was only getting worse and she was becoming emotionally and physically exhausted. She was experiencing the three cardinal symptoms of burnout: emotional exhaustion, detachment from others, and a reduced sense of efficiency and personal accomplishment.
Burnout is a state of physical and emotional exhaustion caused by excessive and prolonged stress (Smith et al., 2011). It is gradual process by which people detach from meaningful relationships in response to protracted stress and physical, mental, and emotional strain. The result is a feeling of being drained, unproductive, and having nothing more to give. Gorkin (2008) says that when “results, rewards, recognition, and relief are not forthcoming, the groundwork for burnout is being laid.” He suggests that, although there are differences among individuals, burnout generally occurs in four stages:
These four stages are evident in the following case.
Dan Caring, LPN (LVN), took a job in a long-term care facility owned and operated by a for-profit company. Though the facility advertizes that its mission is to provide compassionate care for the elderly and infirm, Dan found its primary concern seemed to be keeping the beds full and the costs low. The 8-hour shifts were staffed by certified nursing attendants and one licensed nurse. The supervisor was an RN, but she did no patient care. The attendants bathed, fed, and ambulated patients, and Dan gave the medications, did wound care, wrote care plans, kept patient records, and communicated with physicians and pharmacists. The job was not ideal, but the facility was close to home, paid fairly well, and offered health benefits.
At first, Dan felt challenged and proud of his ability to manage so many responsibilities. Then one attendant went on sick leave and another quit, leaving the day shift seriously short-staffed. Dan sympathized with his supervisor’s difficulty finding qualified help and assumed the duties of the absent attendants, expecting the situation would last only a few days or weeks. Soon he found himself working overtime almost every day. New attendants did not appear. When he was hired, the supervisor made it clear that the facility did not approve of overtime. Now, even though there were two fewer attendants, Dan felt obliged to do it all.
As the weeks went on Dan became more and more fatigued, frustrated, and irritable. He had trouble sleeping and began self-medicating with alcohol. Then, one day, he made a medication error. Fortunately, the patient was not harmed, but the physician scolded him loudly in front of other staff members. Dan was humiliated. He began to doubt his abilities and to think of himself as a professional failure, an imposter. He even began to question his decision to become a nurse. As his self-confidence decreased, Dan’s self-doubt and detachment increased, and he began distancing himself from his coworkers, family, and friends.
Dan became more and more irritable, cynical, and callous. He felt tired all the time, suffered frequent headaches, and barely dragged himself to work each day. One afternoon he hurt his back lifting a patient and went out on sick leave. After months of physical therapy, surgery, and then more therapy, Dan went back to work part-time, but he just couldn’t keep up the pace. He quit and applied for permanent disability benefits. Alone and discouraged, he became totally disillusioned with the nursing profession and the entire healthcare system.
Physical and emotional exhaustion are caused by heavy, unrealistic workloads at home and on the job, stress-producing time limitations, inadequate rest and sleep, unfair work assignments, and lack of respect from managers. For instance, with stress, the pineal gland produces melatonin, which disrupts the sleep-wake cycle, further contributing to fatigue.
In the case study, Dan Caring assumed the duties of the absent attendants rather than assertively addressing the issue of inadequate staffing with his supervisor. Instead of gaining appreciation, his efforts merely increased his workload, magnified his stress, and led to physical and emotional exhaustion.
As individuals become more and more overwhelmed, their sense of competence decreases and feelings of shame increase. They discount past accomplishments, even in the face of objective evidence. Gorkin (2008) suggests that although these folks project an image of competence to others, a voice inside them shouts, “Imposter! You may fool others, but you can’t fool yourself. You are a fraud!” Indeed, the process is not logical; it is emotional. At this stage of burnout, individuals may sigh heavily, breathe deeply, and experience a profound sense of loss, uncertainty, and vulnerability.
Normally, Dan took pride in doing high-quality work, but as his exhaustion progressed he began looking for shortcuts. That was when he made the medication error. This gave him pangs of guilt and further undermined his self-esteem. He could not admit to himself that he was near the end of his rope. Neither could he admit his utter exhaustion to his employer. It is no surprise that Dan was about to enter the third stage of burnout: cynicism and callousness.
As a defense against feelings of vulnerability and inadequacy, many individuals decide there is only one thing to do:protect themselves. Like Carol in our first vignette, they develop an “attitude,” saying to their selves, “I can’t let them get to me. I’ve got to take care of myself!” At first, the strategy works because people tend to avoid unpleasant or brusque individuals. Predictably, the strategy does not work because caregivers are not comfortable being “bad guys.” They have always thought of themselves as gracious and accommodating and now they feel angry and rejected. As they seek to protect themselves, their hostility turns to suspicion and mistrust and they become cynical and callous.
For a while, Dan went along with the excuses the supervisor made for not employing more help. He was not comfortable with anger and wanted to avoid confrontation. He had always thought of himself as strong and capable. Even so, he began losing sleep, felt his blood pressure rise, his stomach churn, and his heart pound. Gorkin said it well: “Burnout does not just harden the attitude; it begins to harden the arteries” (2008).
At the fourth stage of burnout, coping skills are at their lowest level. People are worn down, vulnerable, and exhausted. Their defenses have begun to fail. Old hurts and upsetting memories of past failures and poor choices begin to seep through their protective shield. Every area of life is affected. The smallest of slights and least important omission makes them respond intensely. When someone else is recognized instead of them, the smoldered coals of sibling rivalry reignite. Nothing is going well. Everything seems to be going wrong (Smith et al., 2011).
Dan welcomed the sick leave because it helped him escape the burnout he was experiencing. He had run out of energy and was at the bottom of a dark and lonely pit. He no longer trusted his abilities and became disillusioned with the nursing profession and the entire health care system. Dan’s story fits the description of Smith, Segal, & Segal: “Job burnout is a special type of job stress, a state of physical, emotional, or mental exhaustion combined with doubts about your competence and the value of your work” (2011).
Burnout is the culmination of unrelenting pressure over an extended period of time, often from multiple stressors. Gorkin describes the “Four Rs” that can cause burnout:
Job burnout is caused by many interactive factors; some are due to the personality and lifestyle of workers and some are due to the work environment.
|Worker Personality and Lifestyle Factors||Work Environment Factors|
|Source: Mayo Clinic, 2011.|
Leiter & Maslach (2009) identified six work-related issues that cause conflict and stress in the workplace, namely: workload, control, rewards, social community, fairness, and values.
Burnout does not happen overnight. It can creep up on folks if they are not paying attention to the warning signals. For example, in the case of Dan, he was just doing what he thought he had to do under the circumstances. The signs and symptoms may be physical, emotional, and behavioral, as follows:
Physical signs and symptoms:
Emotional signs and symptoms:
Behavioral signs and symptoms:
When individuals such as Carol and Dan reach the fourth stage of burnout—failure, hopelessness, and collapse—they cannot go on. They must stop. They need to:
Burned-out individuals have used up their emotional and physical reserves. When people acknowledge they are burned out, they need to take a break and get help. Preferably, they find a therapist who will give them the nonpossessive warmth, accurate empathy, and genuineness. During initial counseling sessions, they need to be heard, to pour out their story to someone who respects them and gives them unconditional positive regard. Often their story consists of a collection of mixed-up, disconnected, jigsaw puzzle–like fragment of frustration, loss, and fear. In counseling sessions, these folk, with the help of their counselor, sort through the pieces, examine each one, and gradually put the puzzle of their lives back together again.
As burned-out individuals scrutinize each part of their story, it is not unusual to find that one or more of the pieces is a jagged, unhealed, unresolved loss. That loss may be their reputation, cherished loved one, a prized possession, their health, an opportunity, or some other treasured thing. When unresolved bereavement is a factor in burnout, individuals need to engage in what is called grief work. This is an emotional process by which bereaved individuals re-experience their loss, loosen the ties to it, and gradually adjust to life without the cherished person, item, or situation.
To facilitate the grieving process, individuals set aside a time to grieve during which they allow themselves to re-experience the loss. At the end of the allotted time, they close the book, dry their tears, and return to activities of daily living. They do this repeatedly and over time. Such grief-work facilitates a separation from the lost possession.
Though there are many conceptual frameworks for grieving, the complementary schemes of Worden and Attig (see table below) offer a broad view of the tasks and the coping strategies to accomplish it.
|* Source: Worden, 2008.||** Source: Attig, 2010.|
When individuals are in positions of high stress and overwhelming anxiety, they may not realize just how stressed they have become. They may insist they can “handle it,” whatever “it” may be. Over time, they become distraught, distrustful, and skeptical of the goodwill of others. They may attempt to protect themselves with a defense of cynicism and denial. This does not work because denial is a lie they tell themselves.
When people confront the truth and admit their exhaustion, cynicism, and vulnerability, they open the door to health and healing. In fact, truth does set people free. As soon as they accept themselves just as they are, honestly admitting their frailty, failures, and fatigue, they are relieved of the burden of being perfect and are able to replace denial, cynicism, and fear with acceptance, joy, and hope.
Often, individuals who are burned-out have been trying to be super-beings. They have been strong and accommodating, worked diligently, and persevered no matter what was asked of them. Things are different now. When people reach the end-stage of burnout, they must admit that they are not super-beings; they are human beings and have limits. These limits may be different from other people, but they are real and they are theirs. As with denial, when individuals admit they are less than perfect, they are wonderfully liberated. In the future, they will be better equipped to heed the signs and symptoms of emotional and physical exhaustion.
Setting personal boundaries means knowing who you are, where you begin and where you end, and when to say, “This is my responsibility and that is yours.” Typically, caregivers are empathetic, understanding, and nurturing. All too often, however, they have weak boundaries and easily merge their identities with others. Such mergers are not healthy. They burden caregivers, contribute to burnout, and deprive the people with whom they merge of autonomy and self-respect. When individuals fail to maintain personal boundaries, they may exercise inappropriate control over others and become unwitting codependents. For example, Dan could have established proper boundaries by addressing the issue of inadequate staffing with his supervisor and accepting only as many duties as he could reasonably attend to. By failing to do so, he was merging boundaries with his supervisor and not maintaining his own.
Self-nurturance means caring for oneself. When people who are burned out finally stop what they are doing and get help, they are beginning to nurture themselves. Good for them! Self-nurturance is not the immature selfishness of children. It is a conscious awareness of personal needs, a taking responsibility for oneself so that others do not have to do it for you.
Ultimately, self-nurturance is a measure of maturity. It means taking care of your own basic needs for survival, safety and security, belonging and affection, respect and self-respect, and self-actualization (Maslow, 1968). Practically speaking, self-nurturance means providing adequate sleep, a balanced diet, physical and mental exercise, human companionship, and self-actualizing activities for oneself.
People who are burned out may have experienced high levels of stress for such a long time that they no longer know how to relax. Their home and work environment may have been so demanding that they could not take time for themselves, or they may have felt guilty when they took a moment to relax. Now they must learn to reduce their stress. Domrose (2008) suggests the following stress-reducing tips:
To recover from burnout or prevent burnout, many individuals find the regular practice of a relaxation exercise of great value.
Problem solving is especially difficult for individuals who are burned out because they are emotionally and physically exhausted. Nonetheless, when burned-out individuals take a break, get help, grieve for losses, confront denial and cynicism, acknowledge limitations, establish personal boundaries, nurture themselves, and use stress-reducing strategies, they are ready to begin solving problems and prevent burnout in the future. The four steps of problem solving are as follows:
If Carol Diligent from our first case study had used these four steps, she would have identified at least two problems that were causing her stress—an excessive workload and interpersonal conflict with coworkers. She would have prioritized addressing these issues, determining what could likely be changed. If she had decided it was the workload, she could have taken actions such as approaching the employee organization for their help in solving the problem. Though she might not have gotten an immediate reduction in her workload, she could have taken some vacation time and begun to work with the committee negotiating the terms of a new contract. By taking action to solve her problem, Carol could quite possibly have improved her situation and prevented burnout.
The causes and prevention of burnout are interrelated, involving both workers who suffer burnout and the environment in which they work. To prevent burnout, individuals need to identify and resolve stress-producing issues, and employers need to identify and address workplace stressors that create burnout. When individual workers and organizations address these matters, both benefit. Individuals experience less burnout and organizations become magnets, attracting and keeping staff members of the highest quality.
When employees suffer burnout and become cynical, detached, and exhausted, productivity is reduced, standards are compromised, and the reputation of the organization is diminished. This is particularly true in service industries such as those that provide healthcare.
To prevent burnout in employees, managers in organizations need to identify the specific issues that create stress and take measures to alleviate them, namely:
Management needs to ask questions about the six issues that contribute to burnout in employees:
Individuals can prevent job burnout by addressing the same causal factors as employers, namely:
Stress and burnout significantly affect individual caregivers, the organizations for whom they work, and the people to whom they give care. These conditions are especially common in healthcare providers because of the demanding nature of the work, the personal characteristics of caregivers, and the expectations of the managers of healthcare organizations.
For example, in the case study about Carol, she suffered from “nervous headaches and felt exhausted, angry, trapped, and inadequate.” Her ability to concentrate on patient needs was severely compromised. In the case study about Dan, he could not sleep, self-medicated with alcohol, and made a medication error. His ability to deliver safe patient care was seriously affected. In both cases, stress and burnout directly affected the quality of patient care and indirectly affected the organizations which employed the two caregivers. These sorts of circumstances can be eliminated. Job burnout can be treated and prevented.
Helpguide: Preventing Burnout
Mayo Clinic: Job Burnout
Attig A. (2010). How we grieve: relearning the world (2nd. ed.). New York: Oxford University Press.
Brigham D. (1994). Imagery for getting well: clinical applications of behavioral medicine. New York: Norton.
Domrose C. (2008). Patients and RNs face unprecedented stress. Retrieved January 5, 2012, from http://news.nurse.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=2008112080116.
Gorkin M. (2008). The four stages of burnout. Retrieved November 11, 2008, from http://www.stressdoc.com/four_stages_burnout.htm.
Lazarus RS. (1966). Psychological stress and coping process. New York: McGraw-Hill.
Leiter MP, Maslach C. (2009). Banishing burnout: six strategies for improving your relationship with work. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.
Maslach C, Jackson SE, Leiter MP, Schaufeli WB, Schwab RL. (2009). Maslach burnout inventory manual (3rd ed.). Menlo Park, CA: Mind Garden.
Maslow A. (1968). Toward a psychology of being (2nd ed.). New York: D. van Nostrand.
Mayo Clinic. (2011). Job burnout: spotting it—and taking action. Retrieved December 5, 2011, from http://www.mayoclinic.com/health/burnout/WL00062.
Smith M, Segal J, Segal R. (2011). Preventing burnout: signs, symptoms, causes, and coping strategies. Retrieved December 4, 2011, from http://www.helpguide.org/mental/burnout_signs_symptoms.htm.
Selye H. (1956). The stress of life (rev. ed.). New York: McGraw-Hill.
Worden W. (2008). Grief counseling and grief therapy: a handbook for the mental health practitioner (4th ed.). New York: Springer.
Providing accredited healthcare continuing education since 1998